The whole state is awesome. I live in Northern Colorado and its amazing. What else are you looking for in your new town? What size city do you want to live in? Are you looking for a large amount (well by midwestern standards) of other Pagans? Breckenridge and Denver both allow adults over 21 to have up to an ounce of weed without a medical license.
In Loveland we have about 52,000 peeps and 8 dispensaries. Fort Collins is like 15 minutes away and is way bigger, but still way smaller than Denver, which is way smaller than Mickey's anus. CSU is in FoCo. The Fort Collins/Loveland area has been in the top 10 places in America to live for several years in a row. Link. Exactly how small though? LOL most people from huge cities say a small city and go to Denver.